Crimson Desert's Game Awards Snub, and Why It's Worth Playing
Crimson Desert won PC Game of the Year at the Golden Joysticks, then got one Game Awards nod. The case for and against, and why it's worth playing.

On November 11, fans at the Golden Joystick Awards voted Crimson Desert PC Game of the Year. Six days later, The Game Awards revealed its 2026 nominees, and Pearl Abyss's open-world epic got exactly one nomination: Best Community Support. It was left out of Game of the Year, Best Action/Adventure, Best RPG and the art and music categories. The next day it swept the Korea Game Awards with a record eight wins. That's a strange week for any game. Here's what happened, why people are calling it a snub, the fair case for why the jury passed, and why we think Crimson Desert is worth your time anyway.
One nomination, for community support
The Game Awards revealed its nominees on November 17. Crimson Desert's only nomination is Best Community Support, where it's up against Helldivers 2, No Man's Sky, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and Warframe (Gematsu). The six Game of the Year nominees are 007 First Light, Control Resonant, Grand Theft Auto VI, Phantom Blade Zero, Resident Evil Requiem and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Crimson Desert also missed Best Action/Adventure, which had six nominees this year, and Best RPG, the two genre awards fans expected it to land.
There's some history here. The Game Awards gave Crimson Desert one of its biggest moments: the show premiered its release-window trailer in December 2024, and that trailer is one of the most watched videos on the game's YouTube channel. Two years later, the same show left it out of every major category.
Fans had just voted it PC Game of the Year
The snub stands out because of the week around it. At the Golden Joystick Awards in London on November 11, Crimson Desert won PC Game of the Year with 18% of the public vote and finished third for Ultimate Game of the Year with 15%, just behind Resident Evil Requiem (17%) and Phantom Blade Zero (16%), and ahead of Control Resonant, which went on to get a Game of the Year nomination at The Game Awards (Inven Global, SteamDeckHQ).
Then, on November 18, it won the Korea Game Awards grand prize, the Presidential Award, plus seven more, including all four technical and creative awards for graphics, character, sound and planning. Eight wins is a record for the show (Korea Times). Earlier in the year it won Best Technical Innovation at the UK's Develop:Star Awards for its in-house BlackSpace Engine, beating Death Stranding 2, DOOM: The Dark Ages and Ghost of Yotei (Pearl Abyss).
The two shows disagree partly because they vote differently. At the Golden Joysticks, 22 of the 25 categories are public votes on shortlists picked by critics (Games Press). At The Game Awards, a jury of more than 160 media and creator outlets picks the nominees on its own, and winners are decided 90% by that jury and 10% by fans (Gematsu, Make Tech Easier). A game with a big, loyal player base does well at the first. The second comes down to what critics put on their ballots.
The reaction
The loudest industry voice so far is John Buckley, who runs publishing and communications at Palworld studio Pocketpair. On November 17 he asked why Crimson Desert didn't even get a Best RPG or Best Adventure nod, and added, "To say I'm disappointed would be an understatement. What a shame." (GamesRadar). That's a notable turn from Buckley, who in 2024 told Palworld fans upset about their own game's snub to stop being so dramatic (PC Gamer).
Kotaku put Crimson Desert on its list of the six biggest snubs in this year's nominations, though its writer admitted the game's control scheme put them off (Kotaku). In Korea, the coverage was calmer than you might expect. Outlets noted it had been tipped as a contender and that PUBG, in 2017, is still the only Korean game ever nominated for Game of the Year (Kyunghyang Shinmun).
Pearl Abyss hasn't complained. Its only public response is a notice thanking players for the Best Community Support nomination and asking them to vote (Crimson Desert). When it reported its latest earnings on November 12, the company said awards aren't its main goal (Inven Global).
Why Crimson Desert is worth playing
Crimson Desert came out on March 19 for PS5, Xbox Series X|S, PC and Mac. It's a single-player open-world action-adventure about Kliff, a mercenary trying to find and rebuild his scattered clan, the Greymanes, after a night ambush. A Switch 2 version is planned for the first half of 2027 (Inven Global). Most people come for the world and everything you can do in it, more than for the story.
A world built for wandering
The continent of Pywel runs from the green farmland of Hernand to the snowy north of Pailune, the machine-filled region of Delesyia and the red sands of the Crimson Desert itself (Beebom). You can climb almost any surface, and Push Square compares the freedom to Breath of the Wild (Push Square). You can glide off cliffs, rob banks, hijack caravans, and later in the story ride Blackstar, a fire-breathing dragon (GamingBolt). There's even a mech suit (RPG Site). Game Informer's reviewer had to steal a hat from a talking tree for a group of magical beings, which gives you a sense of how odd the side content gets (Game Informer).
Combat that plays like a fighting game
The combat is where Crimson Desert stands apart from most open-world games. Kliff mixes sword strikes with wrestling moves, so you can suplex a soldier, dropkick another and finish with a sword swing (Mein-MMO). You learn new moves by watching enemies use them, and a telekinetic power called Axiom Force lets you grab, pull and swing enemies and objects (Push Square). Wccftech's review describes kicking carts apart, lifting fallen trees to smash enemies and using water to conduct electricity (Wccftech). Free updates added rematches for 69 bosses in May, with more since (Crimson Desert).
Outside of fights, there's fishing, cooking (food is how you heal), hunting, a trading economy, a camp to grow and a house to decorate. Since launch, Pearl Abyss has added tameable bears, wolves, raptors, lions and tigers, a wyvern you raise from a baby, and up to 100 pets (Crimson Desert). And for when you need a break from saving the clan, there's arm wrestling, pinball and a claw machine.
Players love it
Crimson Desert sold 2 million copies in its first day and 6 million in 83 days, its last official total (Gematsu, Gematsu). It peaked at 276,261 players at once on Steam on its second weekend (TweakTown). Players rate it higher than critics do: it has an 8.7 user score on Metacritic, against a critic score of 77, and 86% of its 64,693 English reviews on Steam are positive.
The comeback that earned its one nomination
Crimson Desert launched rough. Steam reviews started out Mixed, about 67% positive, and the biggest complaint was the controls (GamingBolt). Two days after launch, Pearl Abyss apologized for the keyboard and mouse setup and promised a patch (Kotaku). The first fixes arrived on March 23, and by March 29 the Steam rating had climbed to Very Positive (Inven Global).
The updates kept coming, roughly one a week through mid-September. By our count, Pearl Abyss has posted 59 sets of patch notes since launch. Along the way it added hold-to-sprint, control presets and difficulty modes, then full controller remapping on May 29 (Crimson Desert), cross-save in July, and a free Enhanced update on August 25 with new story scenes, eight new skills for Kliff and five new voice languages (Crimson Desert). The first paid add-on, the $24.99 Charting the Unknown expansion with ships and underwater exploration, didn't arrive until October 29 (Crimson Desert).
Some critics changed their minds. Push Square re-reviewed it and raised its score from 6 to 8 (Push Square), and GamingBolt went from 8 to 9 (GamingBolt). That run of fixes is exactly what Best Community Support rewards, so this is the one category where Crimson Desert looks like a real contender.
Why the jury may have passed
There's a fair case on the other side, and most of it starts with review scores. Crimson Desert sits at 77 on Metacritic and 78 on OpenCritic. Every Game of the Year nominee scored higher, from Control Resonant at 83 to GTA VI at 99 (Game Rant). The Best RPG field was strong too, with Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter at 90 and Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave at 89.
The reviews also flagged real problems. The story is the most common complaint, and Pearl Abyss's CEO said in March that he partly agreed with it (Vice). Critics reviewed the launch version, clunky controls and all (Notebookcheck), and Game Informer found it overdesigned and padded (Game Informer). Pearl Abyss Europe's CEO later argued that reviewers played an unfinished build with too little time to explore (VGC). That may be true, but those same critics make up The Game Awards jury. The game also shipped with some AI-generated 2D props, which Pearl Abyss apologized for and replaced (Game Informer).
Release timing doesn't explain much. Crimson Desert came out in March, but Resident Evil Requiem launched in late February and still picked up six nominations. One theory we find more convincing: some voters see it as an action-adventure game and others as an RPG, so its support may have been split across two categories. That's our guess, not something any juror has said.
There's a precedent, too. In 2023, Starfield, another huge and divisive open-world game, also got just one nomination (Kotaku).
Our take
Game of the Year was always going to be a tough ask with a 77 on Metacritic against this field. Best Action/Adventure is where it has a real case. Few games this year gave players as much to do, and the votes from players, Korea's industry and the Develop:Star judges all point the same way. For us, leaving it out of both genre categories is the real snub.
The good news is that Best Community Support is a category it can win, and fans have a say in it, since the public vote counts for 10% of the result. Fan voting is open now on The Game Awards site, and the winners will be announced at the show on December 10. If you haven't played it, the game is a far better buy today than it was in March, and it's 20% off on Steam through November 30.
Do you think Crimson Desert deserved a Game of the Year spot? Tell us on X or in our Discord.
Related reading
From Ultra Labs
We make games too. Ultra War, our browser strategy game, is in early access, and Recipe For Disaster, our food-fight shooter for all ages, is free on Roblox. See everything we build on the Ultra Labs brands page.
Scores, sales figures and quotes are as reported by the linked sources at the time of writing, November 19, 2026. The patch count is our own tally from Crimson Desert's official update notes.